It is interesting that in our western society we are quick to feel offended when anyone expresses his religious beliefs and sentiments, we cannot say “Merry Christmas” or “God willing”. We cannot say “God’s grace be with you” when we say goodbye, it would be very “un-woke” even inappropriate and offensive.
It is true that it has been a long and bumpy road for our civilization to come here. Our Judeo-Christian society has gone through steps forward and backwards in the last 2,000 years where we have some level of written knowledge. It is true that we have sometimes not lived to our principles or just abdicated from them at times but our civilization is far richer and deeper than this world leads us to believe.
Interesting that we hear “ancient eastern cultures” when people refer to Japanese, Chinese or Indian civilization, just to quote few of them. When that occurs, it is because they are showing us some miraculous knowledge that has been hidden from us, due to the ignorance of our own civilization. The truth for example is that meditation seems to have originated in India and extended to China, and from there to Japan.
In the west, Philo of Alexandria mentions spiritual exercises” involving attention and concentration” 2,000 years ago. Later Plotinus developed meditative techniques. Of note, Saint Augustine experimented with the methods of Plotinus and failed to achieve ecstasy. Later Saint Theresa of Jesus and Saint John of the Cross in Spain were paradigms of the mystical tradition of the catholic church. So, there has been a tradition of mysticism and meditation in the west, it has not been mainstream and in that respect it is similar to what has happened in India, China or Japan.
Judaism also had meditative practices. In the Torah, the patriarch Isaac goes “lasuach” in the field – “to meditate” in the English translation (Genesis 24:63).
In summary, meditation has touched the Judeo-Christian tradition early on. The Beatles did not discover it to the western world, though the prevalent ignorance of the day makes it look like that was the case.
The western civilization in its tortuous way has had ups and downs. Let us remind ourselves how the Swiss already in the XIVth century considered themselves a union of free people where citizens’ rights and worth were recognized by law, the idea of citizen obligation to the state was based on a reciprocal duty (citizen and state). Of note, in the contract for the battle of Laupen (1339) the state was required to provide medical service for the common solider. It is the same civilization that during the XVIIth century adopted the empirical method that was rooted in the incipient power of individualism. The ideas held and pushed by institutions and organizations began to be put into question. As Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak and Ronald Wayne invented Apple in a garage, 350 hundred years earlier William Harvey run experiments to demonstrate the circulation of the blood in his own laboratory, Athanasius Kircher used a microscope for the first time to investigate the cause of disease in his room. Later in that same century two schools of thought about the human body were established; the iatromathematical school who understood the body to rely on mathematical and mechanical principles and the iatrochemical school which thought the events of the body were best described as chemical reactions and processes. And that was the start of a long process that has led us to today. Is it perfect? No. Is it good? No question. If you take a look at the migratory movements the flow goes to western civilization countries, that is a fact. It is a good piece of information for all of you woke people who are still here and have not migrated to Arcadia, that place with ethereal kindness, no vaccines, no social security, no food security or personal security, no amazon, no internet and no spotify.
And if you read the bible (Millennial, Yoga teacher in tight pants, guru of the breath and half-ass scholar: Oh my God, the bible, how retarded this author is, this is unbearable), and go to Mark 12:17 you have the most accurate statement of personal responsibility and tolerance to others who do not have your same beliefs: “Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s”. Jesus himself makes clear that we are our own captains and not everyone will make the same decisions or have the same beliefs but we can all live together, there is no need to mix church and government, my beliefs and our common understanding on how to live respectfully are two different issues. How modern that is ! So next time you see a Christian, shut-up!
And next time someone talks to you about the 7 chakras or energy centers in your body, that to function at your best, your chakras need to stay open, or balanced… you are entitled to enlighten them and remind them that the empirical method has so far:
Described that good nutrition and intermittent fast is best for health, that the interrelation of such events comes through the gastro-entero-neural system, that our diet influences the composition of our intestinal flora, that flora produces different chemical that may act as neurotransmitters, those may impact the local nervous terminals, and that can also send signals back to the brain.
When someone tells you that if you breath heavily you will enter a state of awareness, you are entitled to inform them of their utter and already old ignorance. Hyperventilation decreases your C02 the main driver of your respiratory effort, so if you decrease it breathing heavily (increasing your frequency and inspiratory effort) for 2 or 3 minutes you can go in a prolonged apnea, it is called physiology and it is fun, but the Gods are not calling on your door for something extraordinary (spoiler alert). You did not trick Cerberus and got into the Kingdom of Hades unnoticed. The fact that someone tells you about that as a discovery only talks about how ignorant and dangerous they are. That is a fact, not an opinion.
It is interesting that when it comes to Covid for example, we talk about number of patients with protective levels of antibodies, efficacy of first and second dose of vaccines, technological platforms of vaccines ( mRNA based with liposomal technology or traditional ones or live attenuated or DNA based vaccines). Why is it that when things get serious we immediately go to empirical evidence and hard questions? And it is absolutely fair. But then we listen to ignorants that play as “disrupters” and carriers of the secrets that science and standard knowledge did not share with you. Let us just remember the Wright brothers, the defied the common assumptions but they never challenged the law of gravity and developed control systems over power in engines, in fact they were real scholars of engineering.
So if someone continues talking to you about the Chakras, ask a very simple question, if you have a real problem will you do Sloan-Kettering or Chakras?
When you meditate you do not improve the efficiency of your respiratory system, you do not gain respiratory power or any other nonsense these gurus say. Meditation on a regular basis changes your electrical pattern of brain activation. In the moment of mediation what happens (published already in 1984…. that is 37 years ago!!!) is that your minute ventilation decreases significantly due to a decrease in tidal volume (VT) resulting from a shortened inspiratory time (TI). Meditation is associated with a decreased response to progressive hypercapnia. These observations suggest that an alteration in wakefulness can significantly affect the chemical and neural regulation of breathing. And may be that is the reason I can do the whole swimming pool underwater now. But … oh no is Chakra number 5!
So next time they say Namaste (a hello to the Gods in the Vedas) you are entitled to say “The Grace of God almighty be with you”.
And the reason for this pamphlet is that my heart was broken when I saw this Indian man carrying his dead wife from covid to a far away place because no one would help him. And I thanked God again for living in this society, in this materialistic society …. because materialism is a choice people make, I am no one to judge, and they make such decision because their basic needs are fulfilled, is this society perfect? No, but it provides for far more people than any others, and provides vaccines within a year of a pandemic outbreak, and for all our divisions we still care for our neighbors. So I am proud of being here, I want to work to make it better, but get out of my way you gurus we do need more empirical knowledge, we do not need fables, and fairy tales, our belief system can be chosen by us from the open and rich tradition we have. It is time we start challenging fame, exoticism and ask you simple real questions. Those who want to be warriors and scholars need to be both, there is a lot of knowledge and science, if they are not able to understand it they are not scholars, we should revere intellectual honesty and depth both in warriors and scholars. It is easy to get a PhD, but that is not a scholar!
References
Readings for all those who do not know what they are talking about. They invited themselves to the discussion so if they are ignorant and cannot understand it is their problem, this is an adult discussion.
West’s Respiratory Physiology: The Essentials is the gold standard text for learning respiratory physiology quickly and easily. Originally published in 1974!
West’s Pulmonary Pathophysiology: The Essentials, offers accessible explanations of disease processes that affect the respiratory system.
https://journals.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/jappl.1984.56.3.607 Event 37 years ago there was already an analysis of the physiology of mediation and respiratory pattern.
These are all references I used previously , as you can see this is just a infinitesimal part of all knowledge out there so ….
http://www.anesthesiaweb.org/hyperventilation.php#:~:text=Blood%20is%20not%20a%20wondrous%20fluid%20with%20magical%20properties.&text=Hyperventilation%20causes%20loss%20of%20carbon,binds%20more%20tightly%20with%20oxygen.
Rafferty GF, Saisch SG, Gardner WN. Relation of hypocapnic symptoms to rate of fall of end-tidal PCO2 in normal subjects. Respir Med. 1992 Jul;86(4):335-40. doi: 10.1016/s0954-6111(06)80033-8. PMID: 1448588.
Meah MS, Gardner WN. Post-hyperventilation apnoea in conscious humans. J Physiol. 1994; 477 :527-38.
Kety SS, Schmidt CF. THE EFFECTS OF ACTIVE AND PASSIVE HYPERVENTILATION ON CEREBRAL BLOOD FLOW, CEREBRAL OXYGEN CONSUMPTION, CARDIAC OUTPUT, AND BLOOD PRESSURE OF NORMAL YOUNG MEN. J Clin Invest. 1946; 25: 107-19.
Kilburn KH. Survival of acute respiratory failure. A study of 239 episodes. Ann Intern Med. 1969 Mar;70(3):471-85.
FINNERTY FA Jr, WITKIN L, FAZEKAS JF. Cerebral hemodynamics during cerebral ischemia induced by acute hypotension. J Clin Invest. 1954;33: 1227-32.
Godoy DA, Seifi A, Garza D, Lubillo-Montenegro S, Murillo-Cabezas F. Hyperventilation Therapy for Control of Posttraumatic Intracranial Hypertension. Front Neurol. 2017;8: 250.
Schneider R. et al. Abstract 1177: Effects of Stress Reduction on Clinical Events in African Americans With Coronary Heart Disease: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Circulation. 2009. 120:S461.
C. Jacob, C. Keyrouz, N. Bideau, G. Nicolas, R. El Hage, B. Bideau, H. Zouhal, Pre-exercise hyperventilation can significantly increase performance in the 50-meter front crawl, Science & Sports 2015;30: 173-176
Sakamoto A, Naito H, Chow CM. Effects of Hyperventilation on Repeated Pedaling Sprint Performance: Short vs. Long Intervention Duration. J Strength Cond Res. 2018 ; 32: 170-180.
A History of Military Medicine, Volume II, by Richard A Gabriel and Karen S Metz, 1992.